Vero Beach 19th Team

In September of 2013, Supreme Title opened our 3rd title agency in downtown Vero Beach, Florida. This was the first Supreme Title office to open in Indian River County. A centrally-located office nestled in downtown Vero Beach, our expert team of title agents and staff are ready to help you with your real estate closing process. We make it easy to work with your favorite title agent from any of our six branches, and you can close in the most convenient location for your needs.

Supreme Title, including any new locations, always remains steadfast to our three principals: Accountability, Affordability, and Accessibility.

What Our Clients have to say

From Facebook to Google our reviews speak volumes!

  • positive review  Awesome staff, friendly people, and as quick and painless as they could make buying a house for us!

    Tesa McIntosh Avatar Tesa McIntosh
    June 22, 2019

    positive review  Just closed with Supreme Title today, the ladies were top-notch:professional and friendly took care of me every step of the way!

    Cary Lescure Avatar Cary Lescure
    July 2, 2015

    positive review  Thank you to the Supreme Title team for all your hard work in my closings this past week. As always, it has been a pleasure working together and you are my favorite title company!! Keep up the great job ladies and I look forward to more closings with you.

    KC Pritchard Avatar KC Pritchard
    March 21, 2016
  • positive review  Great knowledgeable people. Make the closing experience so easy.

    Joe Ferrara Avatar Joe Ferrara
    April 2, 2019

    positive review  Great people, attention to detail, excellent work and always there to answer your questions!

    John Cummings Avatar John Cummings
    January 25, 2018

    positive review  The ladies did a excellent job with the complete process , I recommend Supreme Title to anyone seeking a professional job. Thank You J Powell

    Jim Powell Avatar Jim Powell
    May 20, 2020
  • positive review  The good people at Supreme title always do a great job on their closings! Thank you!

    Joe Harris Avatar Joe Harris
    January 6, 2015

    positive review  What a wonderful, efficient, caring company to work with. This company is excellent. Each and every person we dealt with was so professional, while being very personal at the same time. They made the process painless. I highly recommend this group of people and their wonderful company, Supreme Title. By the time we left their office after closing, we felt like family.

    Roberta Mickool McPhaul Avatar Roberta Mickool McPhaul
    April 10, 2018

    positive review  Best service great title company with the utmost professionalism

    Jennifer Alvarez Avatar Jennifer Alvarez
    February 13, 2014
  • positive review  Supreme Title is wonderful! They helped make the sale of my property an amazingly streamlined experience. I highly recommend them!

    Ashley Schiavone Avatar Ashley Schiavone
    June 28, 2019

    positive review  Professional , fair and very friendly ; it's always a good experience working with them .

    Seyed V Hosseini Avatar Seyed V Hosseini
    February 28, 2015

    positive review  Closed on my refinance today, thank you Supreme Title!!!!!!

    Annatolee Rogers King Avatar Annatolee Rogers King
    March 30, 2021
  • positive review  Michele and her team are great. She even went to the assisted living facility where the sellers live now, to have them sign paperwork, so they wouldn't have to come to her office.

    Tom DiBerardino Avatar Tom DiBerardino
    March 25, 2020

    positive review  Love Michelle Paccione energy never have to worry about any details. She always has time to respond quickly to any questions. My buyers ,sellers always have a clear picture of what to expect at the closing. Her experience shows and is appreciated.

    Maria Gruttadauria Avatar Maria Gruttadauria
    March 28, 2019

    positive review  They are a special group of wonderful people, who make you feel like family every step of the way. They help make dreams come true..I was able to purchase my first house because of them, my dream come true..Thanks again Supreme Title ❤️

    Martha Greatlyblessed Harris Avatar Martha Greatlyblessed Harris
    July 10, 2019
  • positive review  Thanks for making our closing today, quick and easy! Kitty was very helpful and patient with us.

    Elizabeth Letendre Avatar Elizabeth Letendre
    October 13, 2017

    positive review  I have closed here many times and I am always extremely happy with their quick service and attention to detail. They are always available. Thanks Michele.

    Jessica Alu Avatar Jessica Alu
    October 11, 2021

    positive review  My closing was as smooth as expected.

    Delbert O. Esdelle Avatar Delbert O. Esdelle
    August 29, 2021
  • positive review  Supreme Title has the best group of title agents and assistants in the area! Always there to answer any questions! Friendly and professional. Would reccomend above all the rest!

    Jessica Torres Avatar Jessica Torres
    December 16, 2014

    5 star review  There is no doubt this is the best title company to use for all of your listings, refinance, whatever your title needs are, use Supreme Title Closings. They welcome you the minute you step in the door and make you feel like part of the family immediately. So regardless of how good or bad your day may have been going before you stepped into or called Supreme, you will be in a much better frame of mind and spirit afterwards. For the Realtors, we can go set up and get some work done in between showings or closings or just to make phone calls. The Supreme Team always makes me feel welcome!!

    Heidi Hunter Avatar Heidi Hunter
    August 12, 2017

    positive review  Thanks for everything! Painless and fast closing!!

    Danielle Joy Whatley Avatar Danielle Joy Whatley
    June 26, 2018
  • positive review  Excellent service - Dawn and her team are outstanding!

    Eric Covington Avatar Eric Covington
    June 5, 2020

    positive review  All the folks at Supreme Title are super friendly, professional and helpful get the job done quickly. They are also very supportive of community events!!

    Chris Parsons Avatar Chris Parsons
    February 1, 2019

    positive review  SPOT ON WITH COMMUNICATION AND ALWAYS WILLING TO GO THE EXTRA MILE WITH DIFFICULT CLOSINGS! OFFER GREAT EDUCATIONAL CLASSES AND HOSTS AND SPONSORS MANY BROKER OPENS TOO

    Lisa Wirs Ellison Avatar Lisa Wirs Ellison
    September 25, 2019
  • positive review  A great atmosphere and professionalism all the way through! 5 ⭐️ !

    Jessa Valentine Avatar Jessa Valentine
    May 28, 2021

    positive review  I had a great experience working with this company.

    Heather Marie Fowler Avatar Heather Marie Fowler
    June 23, 2018

    positive review  They were in constant communication with all parties. I really enjoyed working with them on this last transaction.

    Leigh Dumas Avatar Leigh Dumas
    February 23, 2021
  • positive review  Supreme Title Closings LLC were RIGHT ON IT. Questions answers promptly. Staff kind and efficient. Happy to be a part of this title company family.

    Denise Ingrid Stanton Avatar Denise Ingrid Stanton
    July 2, 2014

    positive review  Great company! Everyone is so caring about every individual they work with!

    Ashley Suarez Avatar Ashley Suarez
    November 9, 2018

    positive review  I had the privilege of working with Supreme this summer with a client. Their communication and timeliness are amazing! All of the professionals in the office were kind & courteous. We could not have asked for a better experience for our clients. Thank you Supreme Title!

    Elizabeth Cassidy Avatar Elizabeth Cassidy
    August 17, 2020
Google Rating
5.0
Carol McAdams

Carol McAdams

Manager

Carol has over 15 years of experience in the title industry. She began by working for a national title company; the experience allowed her to work with customers at a local, regional and national level. Carol was recognized as the top sales producer within her division for 3 consecutive years. A great part of her success came from her continual commitment to expand her abilities and the company’s capabilities to meet and exceed their customers’ definition of great customer service. With this background, Carol has a clear understanding that not everyone fits into one mold. Being fluent in Spanish also helps Carol to meet the needs of Spanish-speaking customers.


Email: Carol@supremetitlellc.com

Don McAdams

Don McAdams

Office Manager

Don is originally from Milwaukee and is relatively new to the title industry. He brings his natural people skills, and commitment to providing bar none the best customer service in the industry. On Don’s off time he loves spending time fixing cars, hanging with his beautiful wife Carol and their 3 adorable boys.


Email: Don@supremetitlellc.com

Althea James

Althea James

Title Closer

Althea James was born and raised in New York but moved to Florida in 1998. Althea loves “all things real estate” and is the complete trifecta: she has worked in the real estate, mortgage and title industry since her move to Florida. She currently holds a Florida license in real estate; and more recently, as a title agent. Althea loves assisting her clients through the home buying/selling process – and she is especially fond of first-time homeowners. Althea is a self-proclaimed fashionista especially for shoes, but her favorite hobby is decorating (or redecorating) her home and shopping for vintage home décor. She has 2 wonderful kids; her son Mekhi is 23 and her daughter Shayla is 20.


Email: althea@supremetitlellc.com

Kasey McBride

Kasey McBride

Business Development/ Closer

Kasey recently moved to Vero Beach from Northern Michigan where she was the Lead Closer and Marketing Coordinator for a family-owned title company for eight years. Kasey started in the real estate industry in 2002 as a Loan Originator for a mortgage company in Michigan. While in Northern Michigan Kasey was a member of many organizations, such as BNI, The Women’s Council of Realtors, and the Traverse Area Association of Realtors, where she was awarded recognition for her efforts and service.

Kasey was introduced to Vero Beach after she met her husband, Buck McBride, who was a golf professional at John’s Island for twelve years. Needless to say, much of her “off” time is spent on golf courses with her husband. She also enjoys reading historical fiction and going to the beach with her Bernese Mountain Dog, Izzy. Kasey is thrilled to be joining the Supreme Title team. She strives to make every customer a “Raving Fan” by providing extraordinary service. She can’t wait to see you in our closing room!


Email: Kasey@supremetitlellc.com

Sherri Reynolds

Sherri Reynolds

Processor

Sherri was born and raised in California, and moved to Vero Beach in the Summer of 2014. Since becoming a Florida resident, she has obtained her Florida Real Estate License, dabbled in property management and eventually landed in the Title industry. She has happily been with the Supreme Title family for almost 4 years. She is dedicated to learning all aspects of the title industry and plans to make 2021 the year that she will acquire her Title License! Her favorite part of the job is helping new buyers understand the closing process. In her free time, she enjoys the company of her friends and family and loves exploring all the beauty that Florida has to offer.


Email: SherriR@supremetitlellc.com

Rena Fite

Rena Fite

Processor/Closing Assistant

Rena returned to Vero Beach in 2009 to be closer to her family, after 25 years in the advertising business. Growing up she lived all over: from California to Brazil to Minnesota & multiple points in between! Moving so often really developed her skills in adaptability and flexibility, while giving her a genuine interest in people and their unique stories.

Rena’s passions lie in anything outdoors: gardening, hiking, biking, sailing, and reading books on her back porch. To her, it is never too hot (or cold) to be outside enjoying nature. Rena also is a proud pet-parent to Roxy & Romeo, the two best doggos ever.


Email:rena@supremetitlellc.com